With video surveillance and societal media astatine a fever pitch, nan clip for new takes connected recovered footage is now, and you don’t person to reinvent nan smartphone to do it. “Man Finds Tape” uses a accepted lo-fi attack to an elevated scary conception erstwhile a unusual beingness starts zapping minds successful nan mini municipality of Larkin, Texas.

Written and directed by Peter Hall and Paul Gandersman, nan supernatural enigma follows siblings Lynn (Kelsey Pribilski) and Lucas Page (William Magnuson) done a playful reconsideration of nan unreliable narrator. The filmmakers’ inheritance arsenic novelists steers their world toward Stephen King territory, occasionally to its detriment. But successful nan end, their thoroughly imagined book pays disconnected arsenic a well-constructed monster movie — one that freshly challenges nan sometimes-freeing, sometimes-suffocating subgenre and format.

Scary clips presented without discourse tin beryllium terrifying, but “Man Finds Tape” breaks caller crushed by tangling up its assemblage successful a analyzable communicative told done dozens of perspectives.  The pseudo-documentary is narrated by Lynn, whose self-directed interviews and puerility location videos bespeak her heavy attraction for nan main subject, her brother. But only Lucas and a fistful of nan faux–film’s different cinematographers are human.

Having moved distant from her hometown agelong ago, Lynn makes it clear she doesn’t judge Lucas’ crazy theories astir Larkin erstwhile they’re talking connected Zoom. When she does yet travel to cheque connected him, nan Page’s location information strategy shows Lynn discovering Lucas successful a catatonic state. To explicate really they sewage there, she’ll usage footage from her brother’s viral YouTube series, Man Finds Tape, and aged episodes from nan faith-based talk show her parents, Holly (Akasha Villalobos) and Richard (Shane Brady), produced earlier they died.

The mysterious unwellness that killed nan precocious Pages indirectly kicked disconnected their son’s decline. It’ll return his sister’s involution years later to fig retired really those pieces fresh together, but aft Lucas finds a bizarre portion hiding successful nan attic — labeled with his name — the amateur videographer wastes nary clip posting it connected nan internet. Like Lynn and his parents, Lucas has nosy pinch nan video task astatine first. Going viral for illustration only “real” creepypasta stories  can, nan spine-tingling recovered footage shows Lucas sleeping arsenic a kid. Who took it? And why?

That’s not capable of a communicative hook to prolong an full characteristic film, thing nan slippery but not unruly “Man Finds Tapes” was smart capable to know. Lynn arrives connected nan segment hoping to find answers. Instead, much questions spark and alert arsenic nan reluctant interrogator grinds distant astatine a enigma her relative couldn’t solve. Reverend Endicott Carr (John Golson) was nan prima of “The Salvation Hour” backmost erstwhile nan precocious Pages filmed it. Lucas had to apologize aft publically theorizing Carr was nan voyeur successful nan video tape, truthful now some he and Lynn are stuck dodging ineligible action while trying to jog people’s memories.

Keeping a dependable clip and clocking successful astatine a blissful moving time, Hall and Gandersman observe 2 of their movie’s champion infinitesimal successful car scenes. The bizarre blackouts are first explained pinch a bizarre hit-and-run that shook Larkin months earlier. The incident was caught connected camera. It happened successful wide daylight. And yet, location were seemingly pinch nary witnesses to this man’s tragic death. Watching grainy storefront footage of nan intersection, Lucas and Lynn statesman their detective activity realizing personification other fell dormant astatine nan wheel.

We get a much friendly knowing of Lucas, and a amended look astatine nan ingenuity of these filmmakers, during a 2nd clang scene. It’s changeable wholly from nan level up connected a “dropped” smartphone and relies connected ambient sound to waste a calamity nan driver isn’t awake to spot coming. Wendy Parker (Nell Kessler) is Lucas’ woman and — wait for it — Reverend Carr’s surrogate. She’s besides nan first of galore successful a wacky formed of section characters nan Page siblings will person to question and reply connected their quest to understand what is making everyone walk out. Winston Boon (Graham Skipper) is nan first of galore to motion disconnected mid-conversation. It’s a accumulation situation Lynn mostly ignores and a clever textural determination that will make you wonderment if nan narrator is still pinch us.

Comingling Reddit posts, matter messages, 9-1-1 calls, and more, “Man Finds Tape” mixes respective types of media earlier giving its villain a satisfying beingness form. Aptly credited, The Stranger (Brian Villalobos) is only portion of that problem and not the centerpiece applicable effects portion of this movie that monster fans should look guardant to. How Larkin’s unseen foe goes astir manipulating minds without being seen proves cardinal to protecting nan town. Figuring retired what its victims tin — or won’t — remember is half nan fun, and moreover somewhat lacking successful personality, Lynn and Lucas waste their bully quality successfully.

Heavy exposition from The Stranger, somewhat evocative of nan neo-western “Dark Tower” books written by King, springiness distant nan debut board arsenic authors. Balanced pinch capable ‘80s flair, that’s not a bad point overall. A pleasant operation that doesn’t break nan mold but nevertheless festers pinch originality, “Man Finds Tape” strikes a unsocial seriocomic tone. One minute, you’re leaning successful to drawback hints for illustration you’re watching “Blair Witch.” The adjacent minutes, you’re digesting motifs evocative of everything from “Slither” to “The Matrix.”

That chunkiness outstays its invited by astir 15 minutes, and moreover bloated, nan climax ne'er gets arsenic action, sci-fi, aliases imagination dense arsenic you mightiness hope. Still, Hall and Gandersman waste themselves arsenic indie storytellers to watch done a operation of distinctly modern POVs and acquainted scary tropes. Suffice to say, nan recovered footage people “Shelby Oaks” swung for but missed gets deed squarely here. That awkward effort, prematurely pushed by Neon arsenic its large follow-up to “Longlegs,” won’t merchandise until later this year. It besides raises a caller question: Can “Man Finds Tape” travel retired earlier then?

Grade: B+

From XYZ Films, “Man Finds Tape” had its world premiere astatine nan Tribeca Film Festival connected Sunday, June 8. It is presently seeking distribution. 

Want to enactment up to day connected IndieWire’s film reviews and captious thoughts? Subscribe here to our recently launched newsletter, In Review by David Ehrlich, successful which our Chief Film Critic and Head Reviews Editor rounds up nan champion caller reviews and streaming picks on pinch immoderate exclusive musings — all only disposable to subscribers.